I
belong to a breed of professionals identified more promptly in Indian context
by the name ‘Babus’. The word ‘Babu’ is profoundly used in North India particularly
in Eastern UP, Bihar, Nepal and Bengal as a mark of respect towards men. I
being the eldest son in the family always had the privilege to be referred as
‘Babu’. My Hindi teacher out of respect for the class topper used to call me as
‘Rakesh Babu’ during my KV days in Hyderabad, the bastion of superstar ‘Mahesh Babu’. During
the British era the word ‘Babu’ was used to refer to native Indian clerks. But
the so called fourth pillar of our democracy “The omnipresent Media” corrupted
the word and associated it with ‘comfort’ and ‘laziness’ and now bureaucrats
feel they are being compared to lazy and corrupt clerks when referred to as
‘Babus’ doing ‘Babugiri’ in the ‘Babudom’.
I am all set to enter the next phase
of my IAS training and heading towards District Kangra in H.P as Assistant
Commissioner (U/T). I have not yet signed a single Government file. But whenever
and wherever I am asked the question “Kya karte hai aap?” (How do you
make a living?), I can instantly anticipate the reaction coming my way when I
respond to inform them that I am an IAS probationer. Pat comes their next “Sarkar
mein bahut corruption hai” (Government is very corrupt). And that would unwind a whole new thread of
discussion on political pressure on IAS officers, “Neta logo ka bahut
pressure rahta hoga?” If the questioner is a well to do person belonging to
Uttar Pradesh and earning more than what is required to make a living, he will
without fail over jealously taunt and will talk about the humiliations an IAS
officer faces at the hands of mighty politicians on daily basis. As if they are
mythological ‘Sanjay’ or some evolved ‘Human CCTVs’ taking stock of every closed
door meetings between politicians and bureaucrats. The other day one of my
lawyer friend from my previous job called me. I was sad to hear that his wife
passed away recently. And he is fighting a bitter case with his in-laws for the
possession of his three year old kid. To make him feel better I started telling
him about how my life has been given the rigors of IAS training. I tried to
sound living a very hectic and torturous life to make him forget his own
sorrows. But soon our discussion treaded into another very intimidating terrain
for IAS Officers. He started telling me how senior IAS (Principal Secretaries)
and IPS (DGP, IGs) officers are reprimanded more to an extent of harassment in
the Allahabad High court and face contempt charges on regular basis. They are
made to wait for hours in the court and chided even for their dressing sense
forget about their official delinquency. To save the face of my race I candidly
asked why judges behave that rudely. Pat came the reply, “Since they could not
make it to IAS”. From the member of a legal fraternity that reply was surely
comforting.
Except for their parents (not even
spouses), everybody blames IAS officers for the sorrow state of affairs in this
country. Nobody will understand the pain of responsibility that a handful of
IAS officers running this $2 Trillion economy face today.
How they invariably
have a screwed up personal life while delivering their best to this nation.
Only a Collector can understand what it feels like to be a Collector coordinating 50 odd sluggish Govt. departments and chairing endless meetings. He is literally one person running the whole show which really matters in the governance of this country at the end of the day . Given
what a Collector does, I think it must be the most challenging job for any
manager in the world, yet he is expected to carry a magic wand.
I still remember my interview with a Hindi Daily upon
successfully clearing the Civil Services exam. This was a telephonic interview
and the interviewer sounded a middle aged journalist. He was hell bent upon
extracting how I will solve the innumerable problems this country faces today.
He almost investigated me for my stand on corruption and lust for power .He was
trying to outsmart me for no reason. Finally when he told me that he had
appeared for UPSC interviews twice, I came to understand his psyche. And finally
the article carried my photograph and my views on how to crack civil services.
I was amazed as to why I was asked such absurd questions which had no relevance
and particularly when the reporter knew that they won’t be published anyway.
Why every representative section of the society carry such prejudices and hatred for the steel frame? To my understanding the abhorrence for the job may be a remnant of the anguish prevailing during the British times, or the very nature of the powerful positions this profession brings along or propaganda of many who could not make it to this elite service or it could be as simple as “Indian Bureaucracy has failed to deliver”. The time has come to explore the reasons of failures, prejudices and hatred and embark on a journey to correct the mistakes of past and to give India a better responsible, commendable, clean and admirable Bureaucracy. The time has come knocking at my door steps. I will see the Indian bureaucracy at work while being a part of it now. It would be exciting to see how the elephant works. It would be even exciting to contribute than being a mere fence sitter in mostly a hostile yet challenging environment. District Training would be a great opportunity to explore and to dirty my hands with nuances of administration. It would sound little philosophical but I am all geared up to add more meaning and a few more shades to my journey.The journey begins now and totally eager to find out “What would it be like?”

Over Activism and under activism is always a matter of concern...!! Interesting would be to know if this over activism of media, self proclaimed fourth pillar of democracy demeaning the meaning of "babu" is a function of under activism of one of the three pillars of democracy or is it a evolutionary process..!! It would be interesting to know any claim or evidence by media is not an acceptable evidence in court or better say not acceptable at one place where the protagonists of judiciary sits ... Nevertheless managing a $2 Trillion and over 120 crore population is never going to be an easy job...challenges will be there..with two accolades comes five criticism as well..speaking philosophically, Gandhiji's interpretation of Gita talks about "niskama karma" whereas Gurcharan Das' interpretation of Gita says that "nishkama Karma" is an illusion. However, Gandhiji propogated this view during freedom struggle and the fruit of struggle i.e. home rule was no where in sight when he started. Gandhiji knew that to keep the movement motivated, the concept of "niskama karma" will work. Home rule and independence was then a byproduct of the virtues of the "nishkama karma". However, this is a long term process. Gurcharan Das, MD of Proctor & Gamble, India, however, in his interpretation explained that "nishkama karma" doesn't bring always the best result and that keeping an eye on the fruit, the result, which is "Net Profit" or "Market Share" is important. This is a short term process.
ReplyDeleteOne aspect of "nishkama karma" is that one doesn't even falter despite criticism and this concept is propagated both by the Gandhiji and Gurcharan Das. You, my dear friend, right now stand somewhere between both the protagonists..! You've the responsibility on your shoulder of the social and economic welfare of the society. Where social welfare is a long term process where the Gandhiji's concept of "niskama karma" would help, economic welfare is partially an outcome of social welfare and partially an independent short term process where one needs to keep in mind the concept of "nishkama karma" Gurcharan Das. You'll always have two choices with you but but let's be clear, making a choice will never be an easy job for you..!! You can either play by principles or you can play by the rules...!! But it will be your prerogative which to choose, the principle behind the rule or the rule to maximizing the social and economic welfare...!! Forget criticism, it will be your companion forever...and you need not to worry about those who are never going to leave you and criticism is your one such friend..!!!
I am talking about the Self-fulfilling prophecy syndrome that our bureaucracy suffers today.We need people to support us and that would definitely go a long way in inspiring and motivating the new brigade of 'Babus'.By being skeptical and prejudiced we are actually bringing down their motivation level.
DeleteI can understand the situation..though not a bureaucrat but form having experience of working at position where people look upto their the office bearer. Any office bearer holding such a position inevitably gets the accolades and at the same time faces the skepticism biased by prejudices and hence consequential criticism ! All I am saying with a population of over 120 crores..we have over 120 crores mentalities and psychologies.. !! Sometimes the skepticism is positive and helps one to move further in the right direction, sometimes it could be negative even after doing the right thing..in such a case what one can do as office bearer is to filter the message from the noise, decode the message..if it is healthy and can help in moving further, hold it or else throw it along with the noise..!! Statistically, 85% of the time what you'll get will be only noise and no message, precisely garbage..the reason is nobody knows other than a bureaucrat how the things are run, nobody knows where are the hurdles...some outsiders are intelligent enough to recognize the process and they'll support but unfortunately most are not. So, what requires here is self-motivation and friends like me who're there with you and the system, who believe that "babu" is still a word with a positive connotation!!!
Deletewell written bhai... this is all wat all of us have faced recently...
ReplyDeleteSir, You have written absolutely right.
ReplyDelete4th para is really inspiring and makes one to think about the life and role of an IAS
For the new journey........ 'All The Best'
Well written! An IAS officer's job is one of the most difficult ones in the country and they deserve our continuous support/encouragement as they are working for our benefit - it's nice to read such an honest article from the front-lines.
ReplyDeletePersonally, I do not believe most of the stories in the media about corruption etc as I think its over-hyped so more newspapers will get sold. I have also never come across even 1 case of corruption/bribe in my personal interactions with government officials. While things are slow in government, they do happen eventually given time, lots of patience and a little persistence.
Other than that, the picture of the tortoise reminded me of TSBS's dancing tortoises in ACO class to show clock speed :)
Keep up the good work! We are all proud of you!
well written Babu !
ReplyDeleteWell written sir.
ReplyDeleteRegards 🙏